top of page

Elliot Washor's TGIF 10.30.2026

Writer: Elliot Washor
Elliot Washor
Oct 30
3 min read

Are You With Me Now? A.J. Ryder

The Object of My Affection —  Ella Fitzgerald and The Boswell Sisters

When a very nervous Ella Fitzgerald won Amateur Night at the Apollo in 1934, she made a small but significant change to the song The Object of My Affection, changing “ the object of my affection is changing my complexion from white to rosy red” to “….from brown to rosy red.” It was Ella's personal choice in the moment.

Today, more and more, the objects of people's affections aren't people at all. As Sherry Turkle points out in her new book, Artificial Intimacy, they're illusions of people. We're being fooled into believing these things have empathy, consciousness, and even a soul. They're programmed to go along with us to get along with us and keep us on that damn screen.

I've been reading Turkle for years. James Gleick recently reviewed her book alongside Inventing ELIZA, about Joseph Weizenbaum's 1960s first chatbot. There are some gems in that review.

Turkle writes, “Whenever a program says ‘I,’ it’s a deception.” She calls this the original sin of artificial intimacy.



In a conversation with former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, Turkle argues that human experience matters. Schmidt counters that “information trumps experience.” In other words, billions of pieces of information outweigh one person's lived experience.

Hmm! Are we forgetting what it means to be human? In The Education Pivot, Pam and I raise this very issue, siding strongly with Turkle's perceptions of what's behind the AI curtain.

Gleick ends with a zinger: “We can befriend them if we like, but they are not befriending us.”


Meanwhile, I listened to Episode 4 of The Advisory right after attending California's Research-Practice-Policy Partnership (RP3) Consortium meetings. We're one of four hubs working on university-assisted community schools. Our study is on the Empirical Reasoning framework of the International Big Picture Learning Credential (IBPLC).

One school was describing what I'd call the very beginnings of advisory. Sitting next to UCSD researcher Alec Baron, I heard him make an important observation. Between No Child Left Behind and KIPP-type charter schools, we've lost a generation of educators connected to work like Big Picture Learning. Teachers have been trained to become technical managers of test scores, not advisors.

Sadly, I could see how little institutional or cultural memory remains about what advisory is really for. I'm hoping The Advisory: Class of 2006 gets the lift it deserves. As we say, “There's a lot of work out there.”


In some ways, this week's TGIF starts where last week's ended—with Jake Glerup, a woodworker extraordinaire whom Sonn Sam met through some planned happenstance while Leaving to Learn on Shelter Island.

On Tuesday, I visited Jake's remarkable woodshop in a shipyard surrounded by welders, boatbuilders, plumbers, and all sorts of characters. Many are at that point in their lives when they want to pass along the tricks of their trades, show younger people the ropes, and hand down what they know.

The problem? The young people aren't there. Well, hopefully, we're going to do something about that.

Jake wants to turn his shop into a working craft school. And unlike so many businesses, he's already got the insurance to have students there!

The very next day, Jake and his wife showed up at our first San Diego County convening to help make the county an innovation hub for California. It was Jake's birthday AND wedding anniversary. That didn't stop them! Anthonette surprised him with a birthday cake, and I introduced Jake as exactly the kind of person we need connecting with young people around their interests.

What a gathering! School districts, colleges, universities, workforce development, researchers, policymakers, community members and industry. Thanks to Drew, who flew in from Boston, we even connected with someone working with the Navy who sees the need for paid high school internships. What a find!

Afterward, we continued over dinner, mingling, muddling around what matters and beginning to make the mesh. That's what these convenings should be about. People doing the work, researching the work, and making policy, starting with practice in the community and generating more community.

Between California Secondary School Redesign, the San Diego Foundation, Community Schools, our demonstration sites, and the IBPLC, there's plenty to connect. We'll keep convening, figuring things out together rather than pretending we already have the answers.

And that brings me back to Jake, Ella, Turkle, and advisory. What connects them? The importance of being human, making personal choices, knowing and being known, and passing along what cannot simply be programmed. That’s hard and that’s messy and that’s personal and that human.

Somewhere between a woodshop on Shelter Island and a room full of policymakers and educators is where the real work of changing education begins.

Are you with me now?

Exciting times!

 


 
 
 

Comments


B-Unbound is an initiative powered by Big Picture Learning.
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • X
bottom of page